What to Buy in New York

New York souvenirs: best gifts, local products, crafts, and what to buy from new-york.

James Cooper
| | 8 min read
New York - Shopping

The Ultimate Guide to What to Buy in New York

New York City is a treasure trove of unique products and local specialties. From artisanal foods to high-end fashion, here’s a comprehensive guide to 15-20 items you should consider bringing home from the Big Apple. Whether you’re looking for budget-friendly souvenirs or luxurious gifts, this guide will help you navigate New York’s shopping scene.

1. New York Bagels

What It Is

New York bagels are famous for their unique chewy texture and glossy crust, achieved through boiling the dough before baking.

Why It’s Special

They are often regarded as the best bagels in the world due to the city’s unique water supply.

Where to Buy

  • Ess-a-Bagel (Midtown East) – Known for their variety.
  • Russ & Daughters (Lower East Side) – A historic spot with gourmet options.

Price Range

$1.50 - $5 per bagel.

Tips for Quality

Look for bagels that are freshly made, ideally in the morning.

Shipping & Customs

Bagels can be frozen and shipped, but check customs regulations if sending internationally.

2. New York Cheesecake

What It Is

A rich, creamy dessert with a graham cracker crust, often considered a New York staple.

Why It’s Special

New York-style cheesecake is dense and velvety, distinct from other cheesecake types.

Where to Buy

  • Junior’s Restaurant (Multiple locations) – Famous for their original cheesecake.

Price Range

$6 - $8 per slice; whole cheesecakes start at around $30.

Tips for Quality

Always choose a slice with a smooth top and a rich, creamy texture.

3. Brooklyn Hot Sauce

What It Is

Artisanal hot sauces crafted by local producers using unique flavor profiles.

Why It’s Special

Brooklyn hot sauce often incorporates local ingredients and innovative recipes.

Where to Buy

  • Brooklyn Hot Sauce (online and local markets).

Price Range

$8 - $12 per bottle.

Tips for Quality

Check for organic labels and unique flavor combinations.

4. Local Honey

What It Is

Honey harvested from urban beekeeping in NYC, often infused with local botanicals.

Why It’s Special

Supports local ecosystems and is a sustainable product.

Where to Buy

  • NYC Honey Co. (Brooklyn) – Offers a variety of flavors.

Price Range

$10 - $25 per jar.

Tips for Quality

Look for raw, unfiltered honey for maximum flavor and health benefits.

5. Artisanal Chocolates

What It Is

High-quality chocolates made by local chocolatiers, often with unique flavor combinations.

Why It’s Special

Many are crafted with local ingredients and artisanal techniques.

Where to Buy

  • Jacques Torres Chocolate (multiple locations) – Known for their truffles.

Price Range

$10 - $50 depending on the selection.

Tips for Quality

Choose chocolates with a high cocoa percentage for richer flavor.

6. New York City Souvenirs

What It Is

Typical souvenirs like T-shirts, keychains, and mugs featuring iconic NYC landmarks.

Why It’s Special

They capture the essence of the city and make great mementos.

Where to Buy

  • Times Square souvenir shops – Multiple options available.

Price Range

$5 - $30.

Tips for Quality

Avoid overly cheap items that may break easily.

7. Pashmina Scarves

What It Is

Luxurious scarves made from fine cashmere wool.

Why It’s Special

Pashminas are soft, warm, and versatile, making them perfect for any season.

Where to Buy

  • Pashmina Shop (various locations) – Offers a variety of colors and designs.

Price Range

$20 - $100 depending on quality.

Tips for Quality

Look for “100% cashmere” labels; avoid blends for the best feel.

8. Handcrafted Jewelry

What It Is

Unique pieces often made by local artisans, incorporating elements that reflect New York’s culture.

Why It’s Special

These pieces often tell a story or represent the city’s artistic vibe.

Where to Buy

  • Brooklyn Flea (seasonal) – A marketplace for local artisans.

Price Range

$15 - $300.

Tips for Quality

Inquire about materials used; sterling silver and gold are good choices.

9. New York City Prints

What It Is

Art prints featuring iconic NYC landmarks or street art.

Why It’s Special

These prints encapsulate the spirit of New York and can be a great addition to your home decor.

Where to Buy

  • Society6 (online) – Features various artists.

Price Range

$20 - $200 depending on size and artist.

Tips for Quality

Choose prints from reputable artists to ensure quality and authenticity.

10. Spices from the Spice Market

What It Is

A variety of spices sourced from around the world, often with a local twist.

Why It’s Special

New York’s multicultural landscape means you can find spices from various cuisines.

Where to Buy

  • Spice Market (West Village) – Offers a wide selection.

Price Range

$5 - $30 per jar.

Tips for Quality

Smell the spices to check freshness and aroma.

11. Street Art Photography

What It Is

Photography capturing New York’s vibrant street art and murals.

Why It’s Special

Street art is a big part of New York’s cultural identity.

Where to Buy

  • Local art fairs or street vendors in places like Bushwick.

Price Range

$20 - $100.

Tips for Quality

Look for prints with a signature from the artist.

12. Handmade Soaps

What It Is

Artisanal soaps made with organic ingredients and unique scents.

Why It’s Special

They often feature local botanicals and are free from harsh chemicals.

Where to Buy

  • The Soap Shop (various locations) – Known for their unique blends.

Price Range

$5 - $20 per bar.

Tips for Quality

Choose soaps with natural ingredients for the best skin benefits.

13. New York City Themed Cookbooks

What It Is

Cookbooks featuring recipes from iconic NYC restaurants or celebrating local cuisine.

Why It’s Special

They offer a taste of New York’s culinary scene, perfect for home cooks.

Where to Buy

  • The Strand Bookstore (East Village) – Offers a wide selection.

Price Range

$15 - $40.

Tips for Quality

Look for books with good reviews or recommendations.

14. Gourmet Olive Oil

What It Is

High-quality olive oils sourced from local producers, often infused with herbs.

Why It’s Special

These oils can elevate your cooking and are often organic.

Where to Buy

  • Olive Oil Marketplace (var